Topic Tags:
41 Comments

Further Thoughts on the Case of Ben Roberts-Smith

Peter O'Brien

Jun 07 2023

7 mins

Since the judgment in the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial was handed down we have been deluged with some pretty strange commentary.  Here are some examples, in no particular order.

Joe Hildebrand on Sky News claimed the finding that Roberts-Smith murdered innocent civilians or unarmed prisoners shows that we are no better than the Taliban.  Memo to Joe: the Taliban are not contemplating prosecuting any of their ranks who have committed innumerable atrocities.  They’re not bound by either rules of engagement or the rules of war.

See also: Yamashita’s shadow falls on the ADF

Another is the claim that the SAS is the ‘tip of the spear’. Part of the problem, the rewards of which we are now reaping, has been the deification of the SAS. This has led to a mindset among some SAS members that they are above the standards applied to mere mortals.  The SAS is not the ‘tip of the spear’. It is a niche unit, albeit very highly trained, established to carry out specific and…

Peter O'Brien

Peter O'Brien

Regular contributor

Peter O'Brien

Regular contributor

Comments

Join the Coversation

Already a member?

What to read next

  • Letters: Authentic Art and the Disgrace of Wilgie Mia

    Madam: Archbishop Fisher (July-August 2024) does not resist the attacks on his church by the political, social or scientific atheists and those who insist on not being told what to do.

    Aug 29 2024

    6 mins

  • Aboriginal Culture is Young, Not Ancient

    To claim Aborigines have the world's oldest continuous culture is to misunderstand the meaning of culture, which continuously changes over time and location. For a culture not to change over time would be a reproach and certainly not a cause for celebration, for it would indicate that there had been no capacity to adapt. Clearly this has not been the case

    Aug 20 2024

    23 mins

  • Pennies for the Shark

    A friend and longtime supporter of Quadrant, Clive James sent us a poem in 2010, which we published in our December issue. Like the Taronga Park Aquarium he recalls in its 'mocked-up sandstone cave' it's not to be forgotten

    Aug 16 2024

    2 mins