‘Slut-Shamed’ Victimhood’s Loose Logic
Men are mortal.
ScoMo is a man.
Therefore, ScoMo is mortal.
Is there anything wrong with the above argument? A stickler for logical forms would insist that the first premise should be All men are mortal. Fair enough. But if you put the initial form of the argument to a large sample of Australian voters, how many would object? A statement like men are mortal will generally be accepted as a class attribution.
Now try this one.
Men are rapists.
David Leyonhjelm is a man.
Therefore, David Leyonhjelm is a rapist.
How does that one hold up? It depends whom you offer it to. To my mind, if you’re talking to those who retain some grip on common sense they will become sticklers for form, and reject the argument. While all can be implicitly added to men are mortal, the same cannot be done here.
On the other hand, there is an increasingly large group, almost exclusively university educated, who will accept the argument along these lines: There are men who have…
Madam: Archbishop Fisher (July-August 2024) does not resist the attacks on his church by the political, social or scientific atheists and those who insist on not being told what to do.
Aug 29 2024
6 mins
To claim Aborigines have the world's oldest continuous culture is to misunderstand the meaning of culture, which continuously changes over time and location. For a culture not to change over time would be a reproach and certainly not a cause for celebration, for it would indicate that there had been no capacity to adapt. Clearly this has not been the case
Aug 20 2024
23 mins
A friend and longtime supporter of Quadrant, Clive James sent us a poem in 2010, which we published in our December issue. Like the Taronga Park Aquarium he recalls in its 'mocked-up sandstone cave' it's not to be forgotten
Aug 16 2024
2 mins