‘He would say that….’

Did you catch Q&A on Monday night, the last programme for the year? If so, and if you have an ear for the sort of comments apt to pave a path to the courthouse, the following exchange quite likely pricked it:

TERRI BUTLER: what I really hope out of this… What I really hope out of this is that we stop seeing this martyrdom of people like Bill Leak, whose cartoon was racist. It was a racist cartoon.

ERIC ABETZ: It wasn’t.

TERRI BUTLER: Let’s just say what it is.

ERIC ABETZ: It wasn’t.

BENJAMIN LAW: Nigel Scullion said it was racist.

ERIC ABETZ: But the process…

TERRI BUTLER: And I notice that when people talk about those QUT students, they never mention the fact that one of them was alleged to have used the N word – I’m not going to say it – the N word in one of those Facebook posts.

ERIC ABETZ: Which he denied.

TERRI BUTLER: We never found out.

GREG SHERIDAN: He said that was not him. He said that that was not him.

TERRI BUTLER: He would say that, wouldn’t he?

GREG SHERIDAN: You’re presuming his guilt on national television but there’s no evidence against him.

TERRI BUTLER: I’m saying this is what the allegations were.

GREG SHERIDAN:That is a racist smear in itself.

BENJAMIN LAW: Tony, can we hear from a racial minority, please?

TERRI BUTLER: I’m not smearing anyone.

GREG SHERIDAN: You’ve smeared Bill Leak, who is certainly not a racist. Let me tell you, Bill Leak is no racist. That is a disgraceful… Your diatribe is disgraceful. You’ve smeared this QUT student.

TERRI BUTLER: I know how the law works. I know how the Commission works.

GREG SHERIDAN: No evidence against him.

TERRI BUTLER: I’m sick of the fact-free zone in this debate.

Today, the Australian‘s Hedley Thomas reports:

The Labor parliamentarian who smeared a Queensland University of Technology student as a racist and perjurer on the ABC’s Q&A program got a formal response yesterday — a defamation action filed in the Brisbane Magistrates Court.

Terri Butler, the federal member for the inner-Brisbane seat of Griffith, will have until just before Christmas to file her defence to the proceedings launched yesterday by QUT student Calum Thwaites.

A 21-page statement of claim, prepared by Tony Morris QC, seeks damages, aggravated damages and interest “not exceeding the jurisdiction of this court’’, which awards up to $150,000.

Thomas’ report can be read by those with an Australian subscription via the link below. Others may be able to access it, but there is no way to be sure.

Read More