The Darling is not being killed by Cubbie Station or any of the other scapegoats favoured by journalists, politicians and the ignorant voices arising from inner-city electorates. No, the answer is more simple than that: it is being killed by the governing class in Canberra and Sydney
As we daily watch disturbing images of a dry Darling River, parched Menindee Lakes, millions of dead fish and outback towns running out of drinkable water, both bush and city are screaming ‘Why?’ Who is responsible and how can they be meted the punishment they deserve? Those questions, while understandable, are not rational — and worse, they obscure the key factors driving the demise of a productive river system.
But before we look more closely at why and how these unacceptable events have occurred, we need to put to rest some misconceptions about this river and recent claims made by Aboriginal people that the Darling was previously a “mighty river” that always flowed. Simply put, it wasn’t and never has been.
The first European eyes to see the Darling belonged to the explorers Stuart and Hume. That was in 1828, and recorded history tells us Menindee was bone dry at least 48 times up to 1960. It has only been since the commissioning of several dams on the tributaries of the Darling and the off-river Menindee Lakes storage in 1968 that the river has been kept flowing, successfully supplying fresh water to users along its great length. That remained the state of affairs until recently, when the system went from several flood events to the present parched disaster in a very short time.
The media have been plastered with sensationalist stories of water theft, political corruption, plus calls for the closure of Cubbie Station and even the jailing of cotton growers. Predictably, green fingers point at alleged collusion between corporate agriculture and politicians. All this is being articulated with a loud and noisy passion that fits neatly with the simplistic preconceptions of city dwellers, but it is mostly incorrect. If political opportunism could irrigate a field or supply bush towns the Darling system would be in flood. When those who promoted the policy that caused this problem blame others, as they are now doing in large part to save their political skins, what we are also seeing is hypocrisy that surges above and beyond all previous high-water marks.
So if the scapegoats listed above are not responsible, who is?
Start with management of the system, which changed markedly when the Turnbull-inspired Murray-Darling Basin Plan (MDBP) was introduced in details that most don’t appreciate. The first was that ownership of volumetric licenses to irrigate were removed from land that could be irrigated. These licenses were then available for purchase by green bureaucracies, speculators and investors. Irresponsibly, these licenses could then be bought and moved from one valley to another. Secondly, the NSW Government exacted from irrigators 15% of their licensed volumes and vested this water with the Department of Heritage and Environment. Other government agencies and indigenous groups were also allocated water from our, the people’s, storages.
The result has been that stored water previously and prudently kept to keep our rivers running and supplying basic needs in dry times has been squandered, sent pointlessly to the sea under the guise of “environmental flows”, “translucent flows”, “heritage flows” and “indigenous water”.
The prime example is the twice near-draining of Menindee Lakes for the dishonest purpose of “flushing” the lower Murray. This was flagrant waste of water and the reason Broken Hill ran out of water and is now reliant on a $500 million pipeline from the Murray.
The problems caused by over regulation of our river system, presently and vividly apparent on the Darling, are in fact spreading south. If not addressed it is likely the whole basin will be out of water by this time next year.
Not only is the Darling being killed, our food bowl and regional communities are bleeding to death because of the counterproductive MDB Plan and the NSW water-sharing plans. While politicians and governments continue to spurn the humility and honesty to recognise and admit that the present situation is caused by their legislated mess of overlapping bureaucracies the MDB Plan will remain catastrophically counterproductive.
The Darling is not being killed by Cubbie Station or any of the other scapegoats favoured by journalists, politicians and those ignorant voices arising from inner-city electorates. No, the answer is more simple than that: it is being killed by the governing class in Canberra and Sydney.
Ron Pike is a water consultant and third-generation irrigation farmer